Rating Scale For Reviews & Recomendations
Post Last Edit by DDancer at 22-5-2009 06:05
Post Last Edit by DDancer at 19-5-2009 09:45
Rating Scale
For clarity and fairness. We really just can't walk around handing out perfect scores. It diminishes the importance of the truly great cartoons that really deserve it. This is just a guideline and is based on a 10 point scale, an introduction to reviewing, if you will.
9-10: You need to see this right now!
10 - Absolute perfection. A serious contender for the "Greatest Ever" title. No flaws at all and expertly executed in every way. Art work, story, plot character dialogue are all top notch. A series of this caliber will set new standards and possibly become a new benchmark by which other Cartoons are compared.
9 - Amazing. This is a Cartoon that is extremely good in most ways with only a few minor flaws. Shows that truly stand out from the rest as exceptional examples, kind of the "Cartoon Elite".
7-8: Recommended - Most popular Cartoons should fall right in here.
8 - Great. A Cartoon that may not make everyone's "Top 10" lists, but is still well worth the time invested. Cartoons like this tend to have one or two minor plot holes or be generally flawed in minor ways throughout the release process.
7 - Pretty good. This may be an otherwise great Cartoon that is plagued with a serious flaw like an annoying main character, a glaring plot hole, an overused concept, ridiculous amounts of filler *ahem* or bad execution.
5-6: Nothing Special
6 - Not bad. One or two serious flaws but nothing that can't be overlooked if you're a fan of the genre. Still worth watching if you don't have anything else to watch.
5 - Whatever. Serious flaws or just a complete lack of anything new or different. Don't really bother with a cartoons like this unless you find the plot/concept particularly interesting or you're a fan of the genre.
1-4: Don't bother
4 - Don't waste your time. You've probably been warned about this type of Cartoon being really bad. Multiple serious flaws (some fatal) and probably no real point other than maybe shock value or something equally immature.
3 - Sucks.
2 - Painful.
1 - I wouldn't wish this on my worst enemy. It still gives me nightmares.
Try to be judgemental about it and its also helpfull if you can tell other Members
What Age Group you feel your Cartoon falls into. Examples:
Great for Kids
13 and under
16 and under
17 and older
Parents Beware |
